Slashdot is powered by your submissions, so send in your scoop

 



Forgot your password?
typodupeerror
×
Cellphones China Android

Right-wing Activist's $500 'Freedom Phone' Actually Cheap Rebranded Android Model Made in China (gizmodo.com) 226

"This week, a 22-year-old self-described Bitcoin millionaire introduced the Freedom Phone, a $499 device meant to be completely free from 'Big Tech's' censorship and influence," reports PC Magazine.

"But it turns out the same smartphone is actually from China, and probably just a cheap knock-off." The Freedom Phone comes from Erik Finman, who unveiled the device earlier this week. He claims the product has everything Trump supporters could dream of, including an "uncensorable" app store, preinstalled conservative-friendly apps including Parler and Rumble, and even its own anti-surveillance operating system called FreedomOS... However, The Daily Beast noticed the Freedom Phone looks strikingly similar to a budget smartphone device from a Chinese vendor called Umidigi. The device is called the Umidigi A9 pro, and you can actually buy it over on the Chinese e-commerce site AliExpress starting at $119. Finman later told The Daily Beast that the Freedom Phone was indeed sourced from Umidigi, a company that's based in Shenzhen, China...

An uncensorable app store opens the door for hackers and shady developers to circulate malware and data-collecting programs to users. We're also doubtful Freedom Phone has its own operating system if it can run apps such as Parler and Rumble, in addition to Signal, Telegram and Brave

The Daily Beast adds this anecdote: The Freedom Phone's "Freedom OS" operating system is based on Google's Android operating system, according to Finman. But during a livestream video promoting the phone, right-wing activist Anna Khait was confused by her fans' basic questions about the phone. "Is it an Android?" Khait said. "I'm not really sure. No, it's a Freedom Phone."
Gizmodo calls the phone's web site "radically vague on the details." There is no information about the phone's operating system, storage, camera, CPU, or RAM capabilities. It has a list of features, but there are no actual details about them. Instead, under each feature, there's merely a "Buy it now" button which redirects you to the site's shopping cart. The phone's hefty price, combined with the company's total lack of transparency, is ridiculous — essentially asking the buyer to cough up half a grand in exchange for, uh, something...!
But Gizmodo also shares a philosophical thought: Before we get into the specifics of why this device probably sucks, let me just say that the desire to have a phone that is dedicated to protecting your autonomy and privacy is a reasonable one — and should be encouraged. That said, I don't think the Freedom Phone provides that. Actually, aside from its overt partisan bent, it's impossible to tell what kind of device this is because Finman and his acolytes haven't provided any information about it...

The funny thing is, if Trump voters are looking for a way to get off the "Big Tech" grid, there's no need for them to buy this sketchy shit. There are actually entire subcultures within the phone industry dedicated to escaping the Android/iOS paradigm. You can wade into the de-Googled phone sector, for instance — where Android phones are sold that have ostensibly been refurbished to rid the devices of code that will "send your personal data" back to the tech giant. There's also the Linux-based Pinephone, which sells at a fraction of the Freedom Phone's cost (between $150 and $200), and is a favorite of those in the privacy community. All of these come with caveats, obviously, but the point is that there are much more transparent and affordable options than the Freedom Phone...

It'd be nice if Americans could actually come together around the issue of privacy since it's an area where — regardless of political party — we're all collectively getting screwed.

This discussion has been archived. No new comments can be posted.

Right-wing Activist's $500 'Freedom Phone' Actually Cheap Rebranded Android Model Made in China

Comments Filter:
  • by DrXym ( 126579 ) on Saturday July 17, 2021 @10:37AM (#61591577)
    Got to hand it to the manufacturers. They identified a rich seam of stupid and they're ready to mine it for all its worth.
    • by LenKagetsu ( 6196102 ) on Saturday July 17, 2021 @10:38AM (#61591581)

      I wonder how many of these things aimed at rightists are just pump-and-dumps with the intention of fleecing their money.

      • by AmiMoJo ( 196126 ) on Saturday July 17, 2021 @10:48AM (#61591615) Homepage Journal

        I wonder how many have backdoors installed to keep tabs on them in case they decide to start an insurrection again.

        • None (Score:4, Interesting)

          by rsilvergun ( 571051 ) on Saturday July 17, 2021 @11:38AM (#61591775)
          we knew exactly who was moving to start an insurrection because they weren't hiding it in the slightest. It was all over their FB & Twitter feeds. This is why everyone who's both paying attention and isn't on the right wing is terrified of the prospect of them getting off lightly. With a few exceptions the only way they could is if the courts just give them a pass, such is the breath and depth of the evidence against them.

          And if they do that we'll have another coup attempt in 10 years, and this time just like in Germany it'll succeed.

          It's time to decide who's side your on, Democracy or the Republican party. And ask yourself this, will you always agree with everything The Party does? Because the window to decide is closing.
          • Re:None (Score:4, Interesting)

            by mikeiver1 ( 1630021 ) on Saturday July 17, 2021 @12:11PM (#61591875)
            10 years? More likely 3 at the most!
          • by Albinoman ( 584294 ) on Saturday July 17, 2021 @12:53PM (#61592017)
            There was zero chance of any coup or anything like it. Do you really think if that mob managed to barricade themselves into Capitol Hill that people would just say "well, I guess they're in charge now!"? Of course not. Quit giving them more credit than they deserve.
            • by GrandCow ( 229565 ) on Saturday July 17, 2021 @01:56PM (#61592189)
              They were 60 seconds from getting into the Senate floor while Senators were still inside the room. If Eugene Goodman hadn't led them away, the day would have had a much worse outcome. This isn't even speculation, in the video where he confronts part of the mob and leads them away, you literally see the door to the Senate floor is wide open. It wasn't even sealed until after the mob had been led away. If the traitors had made it in, there would have been multiple more kills from Capitol police mowing down anyone that entered the room, or they would have stormed in fast enough to overcome the police and Senators would have been straight up murdered.

              An actual change of government probably wouldn't have happened, but the day was incredibly close to being way worse than it already was.
            • by whoever57 ( 658626 ) on Saturday July 17, 2021 @02:42PM (#61592289) Journal

              You don't understand the big picture, or are deliberately spreading misinformation. The people who invaded the capital were mere tools. They were just the useful fools in a bigger scheme.

              Had the insurrectionists got into the Senate chamber and started killing people, Trump would have invoked the Insurrection Act and attempted to impose a form of martial law.

              The real threat was always what Trump would do and how the Capitol Insurrection would give him an excuse to do it.

              • by Kernel Kurtz ( 182424 ) on Saturday July 17, 2021 @04:20PM (#61592481)

                Had the insurrectionists got into the Senate chamber and started killing people, Trump would have invoked the Insurrection Act and attempted to impose a form of martial law. The real threat was always what Trump would do and how the Capitol Insurrection would give him an excuse to do it.

                No doubt. As an outsider looking in I also have serious concerns about whether your Congress would have been completely co-opted had Democrats not still had a majority in the House. If Republicans had controlled both houses it is disturbing to think they might indeed have just decided to ignore the election and install Trump instead. That is how sketchy the GOP has become.

                I am heartened to see the Joint Chiefs of Staff were concerned about a coup as well and rightly wanted no part of that. And props to SCOTUS as well. Trump probably thought his appointments would be his lapdogs. Just further proof he is not terribly bright.

                Ultimately things went as they were supposed to because many folks from both parties and at both the state and federal level took their oath to the Constitution seriously. There is a very good reason people take thier oath to the constitution and not to whoever happens to hold power at a given time.

                It is not over, however. There unfortunately remains a ongoing push by people in some positions of power to install other people whose fealty is to Trump rather than the Constitution anywhere they can. It is probably the biggest threat to your republic since it was founded. As someone living right next door I hope you continue to overcome the malevolent forces looking to make your country a dictatorship.

            • by rsilvergun ( 571051 ) on Saturday July 17, 2021 @03:02PM (#61592323)
              If they had killed Nancy pelosi and a few other members of the House that's possible that the Republicans could have taken control of the House long enough to use procedural tricks to force fake recounts of the election that would have been turned handed the election to Donald Trump. There are several people talking about this plan and it's why they were several people trying to find and kill Nancy pelosi.

              But all that's a moot point. Google the Beer Hall Putsch. This was a dry run to get you and me used to political violence. If you do some research you'll find the right wing has done this several times on state level, seizing control of state legislatures to stop legislation from passing that they disagree with. It's not so much a slippery slope as it is jumping off a cliff. And you're helping them and democracy by dismissing them with the classic it can't happen here line of reasoning. Are you doing that on purpose because you opposed democracy or are you just a useful idiot?

              I don't mean to insult you but that phrase has a specific meaning and you need to think about what it means and what's happening in America
              • Case nobody figured it out that was supposed to be helping them end democracy, not helping them and democracy. I've been using Google's speech to text for my posts and it's less than perfect.
            • by sjames ( 1099 )

              Personally, I am more concerned about the coup that was advocated by Senators and Congressmen trying to subvert the election results and the various state governors and legislators trying to close the holes that allowed the people to express their will at the ballot box, even going so far as to turn on a few in the GOP that had the integrity to favor democracy, the law, reality, and the will of the people over partisan politics.

              Not to mention the problem that we have legislators that actually still believe

        • Since it's a cheap Chinese made phone I'm sure it's got backdoor(s) in the firmware regardless of what OS is running on it, and as the summary says since the apps are 'uncensored' that means that any hacking group from any country on the planet can insert their apps there and more-or-less build their own botnet and data collection/surveillance platform out of these. Also considering how it's described that there's almost no technical information provided about these I wouldn't at all be surprised if the guy
          • by AmiMoJo ( 196126 )

            I was going to say, the uncensorable app store is the biggest worry. No way to take down malware.

            AllWinner parts are reasonably good security wise. The only major issue they had was a firmware image with debug code left in, but it was only a demo.

          • Are you under the impression that expensive US made phones do not have backdoors? It's reasonable to assume that they all do, though perhaps not as obvious as those of a cheap knockoff that is designed for criminal use.

        • I wonder how many have backdoors installed to keep tabs on them in case they decide to start an insurrection again.

          I've wondered a bit about that myself. Those phones usually have an "ET phone home" feature.

          But even if not, let's face it - a lot of the Trumpists are pretty stupid, and are soon parted with their money. So branding a crappy cheap phone with "Muh Freedum!" will get a lot of them to buy them as a show of support for their dear leader.

      • I don't have a number for you. But given the number of scams that fit this description, any such offer should be considered a scam until proved otherwise.
      • by bkmoore ( 1910118 ) on Saturday July 17, 2021 @10:53AM (#61591647)

        I wonder how many of these things aimed at rightists are just pump-and-dumps with the intention of fleecing their money.

        Go listen to right-wing radio for an hour, and you'll need a strong drink at least 90 proof. About 30 minutes is devoted to commercials for myPillow, vitamin supplements, gold/silver investments, IRS tax help, and insurance. The other 30 minutes can be evenly divided between fact-free skewering Democrats and the traditional media, praising Trump, and taking calls from clueless listeners. It's basically the Opra show for right wingers. The real intent is to make money peddling products of questionable value to gullible listeners and groom them to stop thinking and vote GOP.

        • the reason for the insane informercial quality advertisers, even on Fox News, is that these programs are propaganda for the right wing and Republican agenda, and that agenda is so far off the rails (and has been since the 80s) that no legitimate business can risk associating with them.

          Normally these kind of scammy businesses wouldn't be enough to keep major programs going. It's not that they wouldn't be profitable, it's that they wouldn't be profitable *enough*. They'd be replaced by more legit programs
          • I've noticed lately that most of the music stations are now all owned by the same corporation. This worries me.
            • Re: (Score:3, Informative)

              by Anonymous Coward

              I've noticed lately that most of the music stations are now all owned by the same corporation. This worries me.

              Welcome to 1996.

              In 1994 Republicans took control of congress for the first time in 40 years. In 1996 they created The Telecommunications Act of 1996. Like all federal laws it is big and complicated, but it really only has 2 important points:

              Allow more government censorship of radio and television by greatly increasing the fines that the FCC can issue for broadcasting "indecent" content.

              Eliminate competition by removing all ownership restrictions. As a result, today, three big companies own nearly all the

          • Comment removed based on user account deletion
          • ...The billionaires step in, buy up the stations and keep them on the air...

            I'm an avid amateur radio operator and would actually love to own an AM radio station. But I'd play historical public-domain music, replay FDR's fireside chats, maybe old radio serial dramas. It wouldn't make any money, but would give me something actually nice to listen to on my old vintage tube radios. Maybe a few others would also tune in to hear early jazz or swing late at night.

        • by Rick Schumann ( 4662797 ) on Saturday July 17, 2021 @12:13PM (#61591883) Journal
          Remember Art Bell and his overnight shows? Back in the day it used to be ghosts, spirits, UFOs, time travellers, and other interesting and totally implausible content. Good entertainment when you have no choice to be out on the road at all hours of the night, right? These days since Art is long since dead and a cadre of others have taken his place in his late-night empire, it's still those things -- part of the time. The rest of the time it's soft-core right-wing politics, anti-vaxxers, and religion. Sad to have to turn the radio off rather than listen to half-truths, outright lies, and anti-science. The ads aren't quite as bad as your list but they sometimes are close.
          • Re: (Score:2, Interesting)

            by Ol Olsoc ( 1175323 )

            Sad to have to turn the radio off rather than listen to half-truths, outright lies, and anti-science. The ads aren't quite as bad as your list but they sometimes are close.

            I completely gave up on my last two bastions of OTA radio listening. NPR went misandrc after Trump was elected, and ESPN sports and Dan LeBatard parted ways - now it's just different people talking but saying the same thing. Now I do Sirius XM - mostly the comedy and Hockey channels.

            Note before I'm skewerd. Women have a really good reason to have been freaked out and pissed after Trump was elected. Unfortunately, NPR went with the sad tactic of the various canards "All old white men are sexist and racis

        • > commercials for myPillow, vitamin supplements, gold/silver investments, IRS tax help, and insurance

          And colon cleansers. For some reason, after I see anything conservative, a strange bearded man shows up to tellme how I have up to 20 pounds of toxic poop in my body. It's true that after seeing some online politics, the irony is not lost on me.

      • About half (Score:2, Troll)

        by rsilvergun ( 571051 )
        the other half are billionaire funded propaganda campaigns meant to get people to support low wages, low taxes for said billionaires and weak or nonexistent voting rights.

        I'm reminded of an old bit from Married with Children:

        Peggy: Well, you remember when you used to yell at me because there wasn't any juice in the house? Well, I took some of that money and bought you juice... and a fur coat for me. And then when you demanded dinner? Well, I took more money and bought you a bucket of fried chicken..
        • *chuckles* you just described most low income people regardless of political stance. Being terrible with money has nothing to do with politics. Keep up the good fight though. I'm sure you will influence plenty of centralist of how great your side is by doing all you can to attack your strawman of the other side.

          • Comment removed based on user account deletion
          • *chuckles* you just described most low income people regardless of political stance. Being terrible with money has nothing to do with politics. Keep up the good fight though. I'm sure you will influence plenty of centralist of how great your side is by doing all you can to attack your strawman of the other side.

            Been my experience that being really bad with money knows no particular income demographic. I know more than a few people who made more money than me, yet are looking forward to retiring on only Social security. Meanwhile, I took my SS as walking around money.

      • I wonder how many of these things aimed at rightists are just pump-and-dumps with the intention of fleecing their money.

        As the stable genius con artist once said, "I love the poorly educated."

        • As the stable genius con artist once said

          Person, woman, man, camera, TV.

          • As the stable genius con artist once said

            Person, woman, man, camera, TV.

            Dude absolutely Aced his cognitive tests! The Doctors had never seen anything like that before evah!

      • by phalse phace ( 454635 ) on Saturday July 17, 2021 @11:47AM (#61591811)

        I wonder how many of these things aimed at rightists are just pump-and-dumps with the intention of fleecing their money.

        You've even got conservative "influencers" trying to get a piece of the pie [thedailybeast.com].

        "While Freedom Phone’s founder has failed to include basic details about its device, he did line up a massive ad campaign among conservative influencers. Along with Owens, Stone, D’Souza, and Alexander, the Freedom Phone has also been backed by a number of other figures popular on the right, including Pizzagate conspiracy theorist Jack Posobiec, journalist John Solomon, and Students for Trump cofounder Ryan Fournier.

        Many of the Freedom Phone’s prominent endorsers urged their followers to use a promo code to buy the phone, suggesting that the influencers will receive a cut when their fans buy the phone. Each referred sale results in a $50 payment to the influencer who endorsed the phone, according to a website explaining Freedom Phone's "promoters" program."

      • in this Venn diagram between gullible far-right wingers and religious nuts. They are equally credulous and willing to spend on empty ideas as a form of group identity.

      • The target audience for things like this isn't notably intelligent or much capable of critical thinking, they're more knee-jerk and lemmings about things.
        • The target audience for things like this isn't notably intelligent or much capable of critical thinking, they're more knee-jerk and lemmings about things.

          I can concur. When you get into the low populated country areas where you still see the "Trump - Pence 2020 "No More Bullshit!" flags, as the cheap flags fade away to oblivion, all you have to do is look at the properties the flags and various merch are sitting on. These are not the best and brightest people. And many have bought new Trump stuff.

          I always wondered why people who are one step away from having their property condemned think a guy who lived here has any of their interests at heart, much less

    • These days it seems 90% of conservatism is simply a barely concealed grift.
    • Its like the Proud Boys marketing and selling BLM shirts as a profit generator. Cars and diamonds use a similar technique. Youd be surprised how many big purchases are emotional and not logically based.
    • Spot on sir!
    • Fools & their money...
    • Idiot Tax.

    • And it works. My mom is on a lot of far right wing mailing lists and she gets a lot of scams that seem to start there. Just put the word "patriot" in a product and it gets their interest. Oh, and sell your gold coins for a markup after you convince them all that the economy will collapse and they'll need gold to survive. And don't forget, send in your money to Trump the multi-billionaire's legal defense and re-election fund! Meanwhile keep selling the story that anything mainstream is all a part of a l

    • by shanen ( 462549 )

      Interesting FP and I don't begrudge you the Insightful moderation, but... These days the suckers are being manufactured faster than they are being born. Natural stupidity has become a scarce and precious resource.

      No way you are going to convince me that it's just natural veins of "sincere stupidity" and "proud ignorance". Some of them are paid to fake it and I'm pert' shure they get bonus payments for each fresh sucker made. (These days they have the resources to track each sucker, too, so they can figure o

  • by The Evil Atheist ( 2484676 ) on Saturday July 17, 2021 @10:42AM (#61591593)
    Trump's big thing was blame everything on Chinese people. It's the buying stuff from China, where the proceeds go to the CCP, that they supposedly find morally repugnant.

    Of course, going the Pinephone route won't help them, since Allwinner that designs the ARM SOC they use is a Chinese company, and apparently not all that secure either.
    • by AmiMoJo ( 196126 ) on Saturday July 17, 2021 @10:53AM (#61591645) Homepage Journal

      Allwinner have been one of the best ARM SoC manufacturers when it comes to open source support. They are much less secretive about their SoCs and because they use uBoot with published source code they are popular with Linux ARM hackers. They are about as close as you can get.

      Also the idea that the Chinese government collecting tax is a problem is a problem. I strongly disagree with the things other governments do too, including various US ones over the years. Does that mean I should be boycotting any company that pays US tax?

      • Also the idea that the Chinese government collecting tax is a problem is a problem.

        What's wrong with holding Trumpsters to their professed beliefs of Chinese and the CCP being evil and must not be supported?

  • wow that sounds like a bad place to get spyware, malware, and scams
    • Especially since the terminology is BS. What Trump supporters do not seem to know is that Facebook and Twitter blocking users on their own platform cannot be solved at the phone/OS level.
  • by johnjones ( 14274 ) on Saturday July 17, 2021 @10:45AM (#61591605) Homepage Journal

    already exists in Europe:

    https://esolutions.shop/shop/e-os-fairphone-3-plus-fr/ [esolutions.shop]

    https://shop.fairphone.com/en/ [fairphone.com]

  • Perfect (Score:5, Funny)

    by battingly ( 5065477 ) on Saturday July 17, 2021 @10:45AM (#61591609)
    A phone with a lie as its fundamental premise? It sounds like the perfect phone for right wingers.
  • Not. surprising (Score:5, Interesting)

    by Malays2 bowman ( 6656916 ) on Saturday July 17, 2021 @10:49AM (#61591619)

    The number of cell phones being manufactured in the US, without any ties to China these days amount to zero.

      Obviously it is using a variant of Android, but it could be any one of many custom roms with all of the telemetry stripped out.

    I want to see a detailed tear-down of the OS so the claims that this is a spyware-free phone can be verified.

  • by phalse phace ( 454635 ) on Saturday July 17, 2021 @10:51AM (#61591629)

    A con man peddling Made in China garbage.

    Geez, I wonder from whom he learned to do that from?

  • by jacks smirking reven ( 909048 ) on Saturday July 17, 2021 @10:51AM (#61591631)

    It seems like such an obvious scam to make money for prominent right wing figures to cash out on fears and beliefs on their audience that these high level endorsers (Candance Owens, Roger Stone, Dinesh D'Souza) that they should lose a large chunk of their credibility.

    Let's also see how many of those prominent backers also actually use the device. I imagine a lot of tweets promoting this will be done from an iPhone.

  • by thegarbz ( 1787294 ) on Saturday July 17, 2021 @10:51AM (#61591633)

    Erik Finman: Hey Trump supporters, here's a scam.
    Trump supporters: Shuddup and take my money.

  • Still they got what they paid for,
  • Former has a Sucker's List of people who believe and send money. It is not unusual for others to get in on the Grift. Build a Wall ? Sure, pay here. Deep State Proof phone ? Sure, pay here. Why shouldn't you join in ?
    • As long as he does not cross those with money, he will be fine. As we have seen before, a company can scam customers, but the moment they lie to shareholders, they are done.
  • .. to make money from obvious incompetent people.

  • by peterww ( 6558522 ) on Saturday July 17, 2021 @12:27PM (#61591929)

    People who are so narcissistic and paranoid that they gather together to talk about the technical tools needed to prevent an advertiser from knowing if they like Colgate more than Trident. How lucky to be the kind of person where this is your greatest concern!

    • No no. They are not concerned with Colgate or Trident. They are worried that George Soros has paid Bill Gates to implant microchips that will turn them gay. Or worse, falsely disclosing to their neighbors that they are gay.
  • ... a Gnu/Linux laptop that looks remarkably like a Lenovo.

  • its a better fredom phone than the Freedom phone
  • is the crowd that buys into qanon, the election "audit" in Arizona and the nonsequiters that have been coming out of Trump's mouth the last few years, than his product will make him a mint.

  • They ran right into the arms of the CCP. I bet most would still think that represents a win. These are not the sharpest tools in the shed.

  • So the guy hides that he is supplying phones made in China This is just like his hero, Trump and all his products. Seems like a fitting business model.
  • The Freedom Phone site shows a picture of a phone, front and back that has a very different camera arrangement. It might be a UMIDIGI, but it doesn't look much like that particular one.

    It looks more like a Moto G from 2019. Which isn't all that surprising, NOS gets around. Still flaky. My wife got all up for this, but she's an iPhone user and has no idea what she's getting into with an Android phone. Me?

    - SMS won't be secure, even the cool version is through your carrier(s). No real privacy there, so move

  • The buyers deserve to be exploited and ripped off because of what they made the adult choice to be, quite like the criminals who bought Anom phones.

    I find it greatly amusing and it should never have been exposed. Had I known of it I'd have kept silent and laughed in private.

"Confound these ancestors.... They've stolen our best ideas!" - Ben Jonson

Working...