Please create an account to participate in the Slashdot moderation system

 



Forgot your password?
typodupeerror
×
Cellphones Music Social Networks Entertainment Hardware Technology

Jack White Bans Cellphones At Concerts For '100% Human Experience' (nme.com) 294

Singer and guitarist Jack White has banned the use of mobile phones at upcoming live shows. NME reports that the policy will be strictly enforced, requiring concert-goers to lock up their smartphones in pouches." From the report: White embarks on a tour of the U.S. from April, with a statement announcing that shows would be "phone-free," confirming: "No photos, video or audio recording devices allowed." "We think you'll enjoy looking up from your gadgets for a little while and experience music and our shared love of it IN PERSON," the statement adds. "Upon arrival at the venue, all phones and other photo or video-capturing gizmos will be secured in a Yondr pouch that will be unlocked at the end of the show. You keep your pouch-secured phone on you during the show and, if needed, can unlock your phone at any time in a designated Yondr Phone Zone located in the lobby or concourse." "For those looking to do some social media postings, let us help you with that. Our official tour photographer will be posting photos and videos after the show... Repost our photos & videos as much as you want and enjoy a phone-free, 100% human experience."
This discussion has been archived. No new comments can be posted.

Jack White Bans Cellphones At Concerts For '100% Human Experience'

Comments Filter:
  • by desdinova 216 ( 2000908 ) on Thursday January 25, 2018 @08:50PM (#56004467)
    or is this from some record label person?
    • by Luthair ( 847766 ) on Thursday January 25, 2018 @09:00PM (#56004529)
      I would be shocked if it wasn't Jack White making the decision. The record labels don't give a shit since from their perspective touring is just marketing for album sales / streaming.
      • by mjwx ( 966435 )

        I would be shocked if it wasn't Jack White making the decision. The record labels don't give a shit since from their perspective touring is just marketing for album sales / streaming.

        Jack White (of the White Stripes fame) is powerful enough of an artist and has enough fans that he's not dependent on a label to get sales any more, in fact he can pretty much pick and choose his label now. He's an old school musician, so I'd also be shocked if it didn't come from him.

        There has been some research that people who record things with their phone have a poorer memory of the event because they're not actually paying attention to it, they're paying attention to the phone they're recording it w

    • by thegarbz ( 1787294 ) on Friday January 26, 2018 @07:40AM (#56006257)

      or is this from some record label person?

      The record labels are only interested in making sure you don't bring an SLR with a nice lens into concerts. Apparently my $5000 Leica was allowed because it wasn't a good camera :-)

      There's actually a few artists speaking out against the absurd fuckery that is people recording poorly lit unwatchable content with sound that ultimately is little more than a monotonous -0dB level with the occasional distorted blip into something that sounds like actual music. Here's Roger Water's (That's Pink Floyd for the millennials) take on the issue:

      “For my part I would never turn on a cell phone at any musical event,” he wrote, “whether it’s at The Met, The Garden or anywhere else. It would seem to me to show a lack of respect to and care for fellow concert goers or for that matter for the artist. Apart from anything else, how could I possibly truly experience the thing I’d paid to see and hear, if I was fiddling with an iPhone, filming or twittering or chatting or whatever?”

      Seriously I've never seen anyone look at one of these recordings. If they did their eyes and ears would bleed. Why do people make them?

      • by Megane ( 129182 )

        If they did their eyes and ears would bleed. Why do people make them?

        Because their eyes and ears bled so long ago they can't tell the difference anymore. Still, I think vertical video is even more hideous, and they are likely to do that too.

    • Thank god, I was afraid I'd need yet another reason to not go see ...uhhh...what's his name?

  • by Pezbian ( 1641885 ) on Thursday January 25, 2018 @08:57PM (#56004507)

    n/t

    • Re:Who? (Score:5, Funny)

      by DeathElk ( 883654 ) on Friday January 26, 2018 @03:06AM (#56005675)

      He's not black like Barry White is, he's white like Frank Black is.

      • by mjwx ( 966435 )

        He's not black like Barry White is, he's white like Frank Black is.

        We dont need no water let the mother fucker burn... burn mother fucker, burn.

        The 90's fucking rocked.

    • Re:Who? (Score:5, Insightful)

      by No Longer an AC ( 4611353 ) on Friday January 26, 2018 @03:06AM (#56005677) Journal

      Rather than mod you as a troll I'd like to take this opportunity to say that anyone who completely avoids the subject of the article in favor of making fun of an artist who they'd like to belittle by insinuating that nobody ever heard of them or in particular you're too good to have ever heard of them is being childish.

      (I think I've done it too regarding some pop-tart so I can't claim much moral superiority or anything).

      I'm not a fan of Jack White. I've heard the name, but I have no idea what kind of music he even plays, but I do know that I can type "Jack White" into Google and find out in as long as it would take me to listen to some of his music.....which I will do now....after I get another beer.

      ....a few songs and a beer later....

      I can now honestly say that I'm still not a Jack White fan, but at least his music isn't terrible. That's just a subjective opinion of course....the first song even reminded me of David Bowie just a little bit. And I even liked one of his other songs.

      God forbid I might get so bored during a show that I would need to pull out my phone. Can I still bring a camera? Maybe I should just go home.

      I've recorded shows before, both audio and video and it really does get in the way of enjoying a concert.

      Even just recording one or two songs with your phone takes a lot away from your enjoyment of the moment.

      Not only that but when you're in an audience and the stage is obscured by dozens of people holding up their cell phones above their heads that takes a lot away from the experience as well.

      So I support this move by this White guy. I mean it's his show and if his fans don't like it they can stay home. His other fans might just appreciate the lack of phones in their faces.

      • I do like this album

        https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/... [wikipedia.org]

      • Indeed, who ? (Score:4, Insightful)

        by DrYak ( 748999 ) on Friday January 26, 2018 @08:52AM (#56006425) Homepage

        {...} in favor of making fun of an artist who they'd like to belittle by insinuating that nobody ever heard of them or in particular you're too good to have ever heard of them is being childish.

        Or you know, maybe some of us have genuinely no idea who this artist is.

        There are literally tons of different types of music out there (I mean litterally. If you pile up ever different disc, CD, tape, wax cylinider, scroll, and other forms of music produced by all the artists, it's going to be a really heavy total mass).

        By chance, I might happen not to be into this specific music, and I might have actually never heard anything about the artist. Not that I pretend that the artist is bad or that I'm above this kind of art. He might simply be not one of the thousand other that's I've heard.

        So we do what every sensible /.er would do (like the parent poster) :
        We will bitch and moan at the editors, because giving a few key information about an artist mentioned in a summary would be a good idea~

        In the present case, I actually did not register the name for real, and needed to fall back onto wikipedia to discover that he's actually the guy who founded The White Stripes (known for such titles as "Fell in Love with a Girl", "Seven Nation Army", etc.).
        I did my duty to get informed, but I think that when the subject of a summary strays outside the typical tech field, I would be good to give some key informations (again, not every one might be into the same kind of music and some could genuinely completely ignore who the guy is).

      • by mjwx ( 966435 )

        I'm not a fan of Jack White. I've heard the name, but I have no idea what kind of music he even plays, but I do know that I can type "Jack White" into Google and find out in as long as it would take me to listen to some of his music.....which I will do now....after I get another beer.

        ....a few songs and a beer later....

        I get and agree with your point... but

        For the uninitiated, Jack White is of the White Stripes, a rock/grunge band from the 1990's. He plays an instrument and survives without auto tune. I went to a White Stripes concert in the 00's. Just about everyone would recognise the distinct sound of Seven Nation Army even if they've got no clue about Jack White or the White stripes.

        Jack White has been in the industry long enough not to depend on labels to create fans, so he gets to do things like this with no p

  • by Known Nutter ( 988758 ) on Thursday January 25, 2018 @08:58PM (#56004509)
    In before all the posts crying "what if there's a disaster and the Yondr system goes down and all the lights go out and I need to call home and I can't be without my phone because reasons and disaster and my rights and oh noes and I need an Uber car and my kids must be able to reach me and did I mention active shooter and what do I do if there's a disaster?"
    • You know, for a Known Nutter you're making a surprising amount of sense :-)

  • by Templer421 ( 4988421 ) on Thursday January 25, 2018 @09:01PM (#56004539)

    Hope this becomes the rule.

    • by Gojira Shipi-Taro ( 465802 ) on Thursday January 25, 2018 @10:17PM (#56004891) Homepage

      THere's zero chance that it will. Even though I don't use my phone during shows, the sheer inconvenience of this process ensures that I would never attend a show in which it was required. I'm certain I'm far from alone here.

      This is a marginal at best artist sniffing his own farts.

      • I'm on call 24/7/365.25, and have 4 small children who by the nature of childhood are prone to accidents and other crises. Anyplace I cannot answer a phone on the first ring is someplace I cannot and do not wish to be.
        • Re: (Score:3, Insightful)

          by Anonymous Coward

          Good. I'll be at the concert and I'll enjoy not have annoying cell-phone addled paranoid people like you around.

        • by Anonymous Coward on Friday January 26, 2018 @09:42AM (#56006605)

          Excuse me if I read into your comment more than I should have, when I read it I got the impression that you dislike this policy and believe that it should not be allowed for them to confiscate / disable / make otherwise unusable your phone. If that's not what you meant, then ignore me.

          Now for my response based on how I interpreted yours:
          What you said is fine. You should understand the position you're in, and that there are certain times and places that don't make any sense for you. A concert, movie theater, Broadway show and any other such venue where it is completely and utterly inappropriate for someone to be a distraction to others are examples of things you simply should not attending with such demands placed on you. I would also hope that your children would be left in capable hands when you aren't around them, and that you stop worrying so darn much as it's not good for them or you! Maybe that's why you think they are so prone to "other crisis", because your definition of crisis needs to be reevaluated and adjusted. The thing is, the last part of your statement says it all... If you can't answer your phone on the first ring, it's someplace you cannot and do not wish to be. Simple, don't go there. Don't expect others to lessen their experience just so you can live your unnecessarily over-stressed lifestyle.

          • No. Their concert, their right to make whatever rules they wish. No one is forcing anyone to attend. My point is that I *cannot* attend if that is the policy they choose to make, and that is likely the case for many, many other people as well. Better approach IMO: ask customers to agree to emergency use only, and deal with offenders on a case by case basis.
        • I have two young ones and I just figure, my parents did fine on date nights when I was growing up with no cell phones. It's a foreign concept now but the way you used to do it was leave a series of emergency contacts. As for the always on call part, not sure what that's all about.
        • by Pascoea ( 968200 )
          I remember going to a theater production when I was younger and pagers were the only means of communication. There was a strict "no pager" policy, indicating that if yours went off you would be escorted out of the theater. They offered to monitor your pager for you, and come deliver the message if it went off. Perhaps augmenting this policy with something like that would help.

          I know how you feel about your kids, but what exactly are you going to do to help them when you are in the middle of the concert a

  • And shit like this (Score:5, Insightful)

    by Chas ( 5144 ) on Thursday January 25, 2018 @09:10PM (#56004579) Homepage Journal

    Is why I don't bother with live venues anymore.

    Between the assholes in the audience and the assholes on stage...

    Not sure what happened to "just come in, be a decent person and enjoy the scene".

    So fuck them all. NONE of them get a cent of my money.

    • by Pahroza ( 24427 ) on Thursday January 25, 2018 @09:54PM (#56004773)

      Well, you pretty much said it, most people can't be decent people anymore. I'm not a fan of the artist mentioned here, but I do think an artist should be able to perform under conditions they'd like to perform. Siouxsie Sioux for example has -- in the past -- been a stickler for venue temperature when she performs because her vocal chords could be damaged otherwise. While that could suck if you didn't know you should dress warmer or colder to what you're used to, that's her livelihood.

      I wouldn't expect people at an opera to be holding up their phones and carrying on with random conversations either. Don't like the rules, don't go.

      So I guess I both agree and disagree with you. It's your money, you do what you want with it, but you could miss out on some great performances just because you don't want to give up your "right" to something.

      • Re: (Score:2, Interesting)

        I have no problem not holding up my phone. I dont' use it. I have a problem having to go through a process to lock it in a bag and unlock it because of some primadonna fuckwad. As for Siouxe Sioux, I could give a fuck if it's her livelihood. If I'm attending the show I'm PAYING her fucking livlihood. THOUSANDS of singers can sing without exact requirements to temperature, myself included. If I'm paying the increasingly rediculous sums for a show and it's uncomfortable? I'm getting a fucking refund.

      • Re: (Score:2, Insightful)

        by uvajed_ekil ( 914487 )

        I wouldn't expect people at an opera to be holding up their phones and carrying on with random conversations either. Don't like the rules, don't go.

        So I guess I both agree and disagree with you. It's your money, you do what you want with it, but you could miss out on some great performances just because you don't want to give up your "right" to something.

        You also won't see many people in jeans at operas or people in tuxedos at rock concerts, cause rock n' roll ain't opera.

        I won't give up my right to not be talked down to, nor my right to see non-egomaniacs who actually appreciate the audiences who pay for their lavish lifestyles, hence I won't pay to see Jack White. His music is good, but it isn't worth dealing with him, so I can stand to miss it. Crowds may be the target of his whiny brand of angst now, but in the past he's started public shit with The

      • by Chas ( 5144 )

        Okay, going to echo Gojira Shipi-Taro here.

        I have no problem NOT holding up my camera to bootleg the performance.

        I have no problem memorizing and retaining the experience with two pieces of OEM equipment.

        The Mark I Eyeball.
        The Mark I Binaural Ear Set.

        If I have to make, or take a call, I'll get the hell out of the audience (or the venue if necessary) and take/make the call.

        I don't need some self-riteous asshole to tell me how to act like a goddamn adult.
        Hell, I don't even take that shit from my MOTHER (and D

      • Well, you pretty much said it, most people can't be decent people anymore.

        That's the thing right; and it's a big fucking problem.
        No longer can you tell the asshole to stop being an asshole in fear that you may offend them and have a mob of people washing over you calling you intolerant.

        How're you going to receive/pass the J if you're holding a fucking phone in your hand anyways?!
        Everyone's special. Yeah right! Fuck off. Gahh I need coffee...

    • by uvajed_ekil ( 914487 ) on Thursday January 25, 2018 @10:15PM (#56004865)

      Is why I don't bother with live venues anymore.

      Between the assholes in the audience and the assholes on stage...

      Not sure what happened to "just come in, be a decent person and enjoy the scene".

      THANK YOU!!! If that's how you feel about live music in 2018, you're either going to the wrong shows or YOU'RE the one we don't want there. Most of the festival and one-off shows I see are a good time with no crowd problems. I generally avoid stadiums and large arenas because you are too far away to see anything and the prices are too high, but smaller theaters and clubs provide the same great experience the always have.

      Humanity's biggest problem is not that it suddenly changed, it's people writing off the next generation or the current times as past prime and heading downhill. The same phenomenon can be seen in some of the oldest historical accounts and literature we know. It just means you're crotchety. Most people are still good, decent people.

      • by Chas ( 5144 )

        I'm probably going to the wrong shows.

        And yeah, I'm probably crotchety.

        But I've been this way all my life. I have a low tolerance for people being jackasses, and an even lower tolerance for random nobodies trying to tell me what to do just because they think they're entitled to.

    • Not sure what happened to "just come in, be a decent person and enjoy the scene".

      Like the people at this concert [youtube.com]?

    • Just go to outdoor, multi-day music festivals for live music. Not only do you get to see a lot of great acts that you've probably never heard of before, but most people there are too stoned to care about dragging out their phone to capture the moment because they're too busy being in it.

      And if some people do haul out the phones or act like obnoxious shits, you can personally be too stoned to get bothered by any of it.
    • Part of being decent is not shoving your mobile in everyone's face constantly.

  • bye! (Score:5, Interesting)

    by markdavis ( 642305 ) on Thursday January 25, 2018 @09:13PM (#56004597)

    >"Singer and guitarist Jack White has banned the use of mobile phones at upcoming live shows. NME reports that the policy will be strictly enforced, requiring concert-goers to lock up their smartphones in pouches." "

    I have no interest in interacting with my cell phone during a concert (or movie or any other type of paid entertainment). But tell me I have to lock up my phone in a "pouch" and you can shove your concert where the sun doesn't shine. I am so tired of the lowest-common-denominator ruining everything for everyone. Either they ruin it directly by being rude, annoying, and/or irresponsible, or ruin it indirectly due to places creating draconian rules/procedures to try and combat it.

    • Re:bye! (Score:4, Insightful)

      by swillden ( 191260 ) <shawn-ds@willden.org> on Thursday January 25, 2018 @10:43PM (#56005019) Journal

      But tell me I have to lock up my phone in a "pouch" and you can shove your concert where the sun doesn't shine.

      So, you like going to a concert and looking over a sea of glowing cellphone screens when you look at the stage?

      I find it unfortunate that this is necessary. But I do see the value.

      • The sea of cellphones is no different that flashes from cameras at the Olympics, or sight of raised lighters at concerts in the past - it is part of the concert experience which evolves with time. Heck, I could even argue that a cell phone is safer than a live flame. Artists use new technologies, so do the audiences. Want a private concert with the artist without any electronics (no cell phones, no lights, no microphones, no speakers) - maybe there are some people who crave this kind of old-school experienc

      • But tell me I have to lock up my phone in a "pouch" and you can shove your concert where the sun doesn't shine.

        So, you like going to a concert and looking over a sea of glowing cellphone screens when you look at the stage?

        I find it unfortunate that this is necessary. But I do see the value.

        You know, my most recent concert experience (Evanescence, December 2017) there was plenty of cell phone use, but it wasn't even on the same order of magnitude for annoyance as the yelling and screaming. "You're beautiful." "I love you." "Will you marry me?" Seriously, shut up and let the lady sing, you drunk assholes. Cell phones? Meh. Not an issue. But we all have our pet peeves. Mine is evidently jerks ruining quiet/sensitive moments in live music.

    • Locking your phone up for an hour is "draconian"? You may want to get some help for that. That sounds like addiction.
    • But tell me I have to lock up my phone in a "pouch" and you can shove your concert where the sun doesn't shine.

      If people were decent then we wouldn't need rules about decency.

    • I am so tired of the lowest-common-denominator ruining everything for everyone. Either they ruin it directly by being rude, annoying, and/or irresponsible, or ruin it indirectly due to places creating draconian rules/procedures to try and combat it.

      Where have you been for the last thousands and thousands of years man? This has literally been going on since the beginning of civilization because there are a lot of people out there who are selfish, stupid, or both.

  • Yondr? What's that? (Score:3, Interesting)

    by Anonymous Coward on Thursday January 25, 2018 @09:20PM (#56004627)

    Hmm:

    "Yondr uses a patented system to create phone-free spaces for artists, educators, organizations and individuals."

    THEY GOT A PATENT? FOR PUTTING PHONES IN A BAG SEALED WITH CLOTHING SECURITY TAGS?

    • by Pascoea ( 968200 )

      THEY GOT A PATENT? FOR PUTTING PHONES IN A BAG SEALED WITH CLOTHING SECURITY TAGS?

      If it's so blindingly simple why didn't you invent it? Most everything seems easy once someone has done it already.

  • If you use your phone to monitor your blood glucose, but the venue forces your phone to be locked into a Yondr bag, are there ADA repercussions? Seems that the answer would be "yes".

    For example, an ADA-related consent order: https://www.ada.gov/sfxinc.htm6/ [ada.gov], and this line specifically: "Clear Channel Entertainment agrees not to discriminate against any guest with diabetes with regard to their bringing diabetes related medical equipment or diabetes related food into a concert venue.â

    I sent a brief, poli

    • I asked Yondr again. They replied immediately this time: We have a special wristband for ADA requests that allows guests to keep their phones unlocked. A Yondr representative can issue these wristbands at the venue. So... there you go. And thanks for reminding me why I long ago stopped participating in Slashdot discussions.
  • Or will a magnet be enough to open the pouches without damage?

  • Let's watch (Score:5, Funny)

    by JThundley ( 631154 ) on Thursday January 25, 2018 @10:39PM (#56004995)

    "Let's watch my recording of the concert I went to!"
    -Nobody ever

    • Comment removed based on user account deletion
  • by Patent Lover ( 779809 ) on Thursday January 25, 2018 @11:47PM (#56005275)
    Prince and others did it years ago: https://petapixel.com/2013/08/... [petapixel.com]
  • I understand all the annoyance with phones but I typically go with several friends or family and use the phone to re-connect and get together at the end. It is a huge pain in the ass to wait at the car for hours when you can just text or call each other and find out someone was lucky to go back stage or they got hurt or they were locked up for some reason. No a phone is a lot more than just videoing a concert or holding up as a lighter. For me deal killer.
  • by account_deleted ( 4530225 ) on Friday January 26, 2018 @04:43AM (#56005847)
    Comment removed based on user account deletion
    • Chances are it's some shitty pop concert then.
      People go to concerts because they like the band.

      Music festivals on the other hand... this can go both ways.

  • I HATE when someone, anyone, pompously imposes a sense of "experience" on anyone else - since, to some extent, what constitutes one experiencing it is relative to one's point of view... not to mention a very slight annoyance at an observation I make where those who chime in with this experince-superioity-complex as I call it often miss you don't need to literally have your face in your phone to not suck at recording
  • I went to a HIM show with my wife a few months back, and she wanted to stand further back so as to avoid the pushing/prodding that happens closer to the front. The sea of screens in front of me was seriously fucking annoying. I don't get why people feel the need to record songs and shit on their phone... the quality when you see them is generally shit, so why bother?
  • by Revek ( 133289 )

    If you've never heard of him does he really exist?

  • No worries. I have a phone on my wrist, a phone on my pocket, and a backup phone in my wife's purse. Good luck with putting the throw away phone in a bag.

For God's sake, stop researching for a while and begin to think!

Working...