What A Portable Media Center Might Look Like 143
An anonymous reader writes "From the Redmond's answer to iPOD dept... While wandering the exhibitor aisles at Embedded DevCon, we were drawn to this slick looking reference design board in the Freescale (formerly Motorola Semiconductor) booth. The Portable Media Player Reference Design, a.k.a. "Jazz", is based on a Freescale i.MX21 embedded processor, runs Windows CE, and is compliant with Microsoft's Portable Media Center (PMC) standard. PMCs, Microsoft's answer to the iPOD, will initially support digital music and videos, digitally recorded television shows, and digital photos."
Not an iPod killer (Score:5, Interesting)
In short: this looks like it has exactly the same features and price point as the device I traded in for my iPod, a Toshiba PocketPC. And just like the PocketPC, it'll have limited appeal which becomes even MORE limited when Joe Q. Fancydevice realizes how hard it is to get first run movies onto it...i mean, how fast can the processor be in these things and still keep battery life?
Still, competition is good for the industry. The market pressure will force Apple to make iTunes even better (and there's room for that). But I don't think they have too much to worry about...a bigass laptop wannabe is NOT in the same league as a tiny little music device.
Re:Not an iPod killer (Score:5, Insightful)
Re:Not an iPod killer (Score:3, Interesting)
Re:Not an iPod killer (Score:1)
Re:Not an iPod killer (Score:4, Insightful)
Re:Not an iPod killer (Score:4, Insightful)
Re:Not an iPod killer (Score:2)
Re:Not an iPod killer (Score:5, Insightful)
Yes it plays MP3's, VCD's, etc etc and uses hard drives for storage (they might have a CF version, I don't recall), but its definately not an iPod competitor based on its dimensions alone. It is still _VERY_ cool, and I wonder if their intention is to turn this into some sort of Game Boy Advanced device a-la XBox Embedded or something to that effect. That would be pretty cool....
Resolution's Too Low - 320x240 + LDTV (Score:2)
Re:Resolution's Too Low - 320x240 + LDTV (Score:2)
Re:Resolution's Too Low - 320x240 + LDTV (Score:1)
Half the resolution [palmone.com] is "great"?
Re:Resolution's Too Low - 320x240 + LDTV (Score:2)
Most PalmOS devices these days run at 320x320 or 320x480. Just thought you might like to know.
Bander
Re:Not an iPod killer (Score:2)
Re:Not an iPod killer (Score:3, Interesting)
I'll bet that Apple already has an answer to that thing anyways. Somewhere deep in their R&D department has to been an iPod with a color screen that plays Quicktime video files. It wouldn't surprise me if Jobs hasn't already started talking to video production companies asking them for the rights to distribute their shows. Want a copy of Frontline, Simpsons or "Good Eats"? It will cost you a $.99 for a 30 day copy. Remember, DRM can be adde
Come Again? (Score:2)
You're kidding, right?
Not widescreen (Score:4, Interesting)
Ahh yes, that "old" saying.... (?) (Score:5, Funny)
Windows CE - The Pontiac of Operating Systems.
Re:Ahh yes, that "old" saying.... (?) (Score:3, Funny)
It's a curious coincidence that that acronym "P.O.S." stands for something else Windows CE is often called.
Re:Not widescreen (Score:2)
Re:Not widescreen (Score:1)
I've got a Portable Media Center right HERE! (Score:1, Flamebait)
Re:I've got a Portable Media Center right HERE! (Score:2)
Ogg support anyone? (Score:3, Interesting)
Re:Ogg support anyone? (Score:3, Informative)
http://www.iriverswitzerland.com/product/pmp140
Re:Ogg support anyone? (Score:2, Insightful)
Re:Ogg support anyone? (Score:4, Informative)
Get the Neuros. [neurosaudio.com] It supports ogg, has open source software, and is fairly inexpensive.
Re:Ogg support anyone? (Score:2)
Re:Ogg support anyone? (Score:1)
Video Screens (Score:4, Insightful)
"feature" (Score:5, Funny)
When the weight of the stack of EULAs equals that of the product, Microsoft releases.
Re:"feature" (Score:3, Funny)
Pre-emptive?? (Score:3, Funny)
What the hell is pre-emptive in this case.. it does something before you tell it to? That's not so much clever as scary
Also, "Real-time".. er, isn't it supposed to be realtime? Would be a tad annoying if it did it 5 mins after (aka Windows ME)
Lastly, just cos everyone else has and I want a go...:
Yes, but does it run linux?
Re:Pre-emptive?? (Score:2)
How about a pre-emptive DRM that works in real time? It pre-empts you from doing something before you do it.
Re:Pre-emptive?? (Score:1, Informative)
Re:Pre-emptive?? (Score:1)
I wonder how much processor time is given to deciding how much processor time should be given to each process? (note: this is a joke, not a serious question)
Re:Pre-emptive?? (Score:1)
Put Linux, XINE, and MAME on this... (Score:3, Insightful)
Before everyone gets in an uproar over the word 'Microsoft', remember that this device simply follows the standard Microsoft created.
It's based on an ARM processor, so should this device ever take off, the ARM Linux port could easily be customized to take advantage of all the features.
This could also be used as a MP3/video player for your living room stereo and TV, connected to the server via the built in ethernet.
Also, if you look carefully at this larger view [windowsfordevices.com], notice the device could make a really cool portable gaming device. Imagine running MAME on this...
Of course, if Linux were loaded on the device we would not need to worry about silly things such as DRM (included in the Microsoft specification.)
Re:Put Linux, XINE, and MAME on this... (Score:1)
And at least some of the onboard devices will also be supported in Linux. A port of the i.MX21 ADS board is in the works, which has a fair amount of overlap with the Jazz board.
Freescale vs Mot. semi (Score:3, Interesting)
Does anyone know what the roadmap is for their 16bit MCU lines? Perhaps I should be using Renesas or go 8bit AVR...
Some missing features... (Score:5, Funny)
My Music
My Movies
My TV Shows
My Pictures
Settings
They forgot to include :
My MPAA lawsuits
My RIAA lawsuits
My upcoming jail terms
DirectPay (TM) money transfer
It's about time somebody came up with a Personal Lawsuit Origanizer.
Re:Some missing features... (Score:3, Funny)
Re:Some missing features... (Score:3, Funny)
And Settings? Who needs to adjust settings? What are you? Some terrorist trying to run "linux"?
Re:Some missing features... (Score:1)
I've finally given up and moved those directories into My Documents since all the dialogs keep resetting to look under My Documents first.
I suppose the real problem is a lack of symbolic links.
Re:Some missing features... (Score:2)
God, that's annoying!!! I suppose there must be a registry hack for this, but I haven't really bothered to look for it. I simply gave up and now use My Documents, as well.
customizing file open dlg (Score:1)
If you want to actually customize the places bar, download the tweakui [microsoft.com] powertoy [microsoft.com], and go to "common dialogs"->"places bar", and enter your own folders. (if you don't want to download anything, just add Place0,
Re:customizing file open dlg (Score:2)
Except that it's amazing how many applications break or fail to install if "My Documents" isn't on the C: in the standard location. (I used to point MyDocs at a server share point so that all of the PCs that I use had a common MyDoc folder.)
better name.... (Score:2, Funny)
It needs a better name. One that characterizes its functionality, and portability.
Let me be the first to suggest "omni-pr0n-sent."
More of a PVR (Score:2, Interesting)
Re:More of a PVR (Score:1)
Once a small video player comes with an equivalent to headphones for sound (goggles?), it may be practical. Im not holding my breath!
Re:More of a PVR (Score:1)
Re:More of a PVR (Score:2)
Re:More of a PVR (Score:2, Funny)
Come on, can't you nerds take a joke?
Not impressed (Score:4, Insightful)
There is little doubt that MS stifled innovation in software. Just the fact that jobs could tweak an open source project to tripple the speed of a web browser over IE, when IE has had a clear field to innovate for five years or more, speaks volumes about the MS innovation stifle field. How could apple even dream they could technologically beat MS in the Power point market, but they did.
Does anyone else find these MS offerings utterly tepid compared to Apple innovation the day before?
M$ gates announces a recylced idea for a portable that shows sport scores, headlines, and plays RIAA/MPAA approved media. The debut the smartScreen, a 1500$ screen-only that hooks to your compute by wi-fi but cant play movies or mp3s, then they announce that anyone who already bought was is out of luck since that they will be changing the specs to use 802.11a to get better bandwidth for movies. then an oversized so-called "video" ipod that also cant show DVD movies, for more bucks than a ipod.
The only thing I thought was interesting was that they decided to switch to 802.11a for the smartScreens and not 802.11g. I dont know much about these standards except what Jobs said. 802.11a is dead, because it is not backwards compatible with 802.11b hotspots whereas 802.11g is.
How is it possible that one company can lead the entire market year after year going back all the way to the taming of dynamic memory. While the other company can lead the bussiness world and innovate nothing.
Funny paraphrasing brough to mind... (Score:2)
How is it possible that one company can lead the entire market year after year going back all the way to the taming of dynamic memory. While the other company can lead the bussiness world and innovate nothing.
Caused a funny paraphrasing to pop into my head...
"If Apple did not exist, it would be nessecary for Microsoft to create them"
(apologies to Voltaire)
Re:Not impressed (Score:2)
Usually when I do, it's not because the product sounds stupid, it's because of my attitude about Microsoft. It's hard to give them the benefit of the doubt.
Digtal music is not the only selling point (Score:1)
Or maybe, just think, Jerry Springer on the run?
Maybe they can make it interface with camera phones, and store them and stuff on a bigger screen than a phone
Pocket PC (Score:3, Interesting)
You need to re-encode your mpegs or avis to a PPC friendly bitrate, but its not that tough.
Re:Pocket PC (Score:1)
Re:Pocket PC (Score:2)
Right approach (Score:5, Insightful)
Walkman, before this, was popular not because it offered equalizer (it didnt), radio (initially, it didnt), multiple headphone jacks etc. It was popular because it was simple.
If you want to make a iPod killer, make a device that is simple to use, good 'OS' (that has AI like remember my favorites and gives them priority in random mode), practical capacity (not insane sizes like 40GB, who has or wants 10,000 songs on their palm?).
Oh, it also has to look cool and not be a commodity. And, did I say, no DRM?
Re:Right approach (Score:2, Insightful)
I don't want an "iPod killer". To me, iPod was stillborn. I can get an mp3 cd player for 20 bucks with all the simplicity you crave, and capacity I need.
A portable audio/video media player is a wholly new market, and something I may actually be interested in. It's "something I don't already have", as opposed to "something that does exactly what the thing you already have does, but just a bit different, and for 15x the price".
The potential hackability of thi
Re:Right approach (Score:2)
But, I think I agree with you that personal, portable media players will become an important mainstream piece of technology. Everything I've seen so far is trying to be an iPod. That's just silly. Nobody wants to hold Battlestar galactica at arm's length. Its a PITA. I think Head M
Re:Right approach (Score:1)
In the begining, one offered stability and simplicity, and the other features and integration.
At very first, the features and integration is not reliable, expensive and bulky. But as technology improves, price drops, and becoming more and more reliable: useres are willing to adop these extra benefits for a small premium. The leader of the race is soon getting caugthup by the the bulky and slow turtle.
however, unlike the PDA war, raging in both the busi
They'll cross it with a Cell Phone too. (Score:2)
My thing is some one needs to get personnal mobile input down and quick. Entering any data on a c
Did they offer it to you for 50 bucks? (Score:1)
That's what it's meant to cost [slashdot.org], isn't it?!
By the way, for the funky Apple capitalization impaired, it's:
iPod, iTunes, and iMac.
Not iPOD, Ipod, or IPod.
Re:Did they offer it to you for 50 bucks? (Score:1)
http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewI
it's alittle more like $550
OK... (Score:1)
Re:OK... (Score:1, Troll)
Um think about what you just said. If the iPod were the size of the hard drive in it, the hard drive would have to be on the outside. The iPod is nearly as small as the hard drive, not the same size.
Having "JAZZ!" attached as Device Name (Score:3, Interesting)
Some kind of Name a little more media savy or Market Targetable.
Re:Having "JAZZ!" attached as Device Name (Score:1)
At any rate, when IOMega's Jaz drive (only one z) came out, I immediately thought of the "Jazz 16" soundblaster clone I had in my computer at the time. My sound card was robust and stable and never gave me any problems.
Re:Having "JAZZ!" attached as Device Name (Score:1)
Sony U50 / U70 ? (Score:4, Informative)
True they are expensive at USD 1,500 and USD 1,700
But they are a full-blown computer with a Celery M 900 o Centrino 1Ghz.
I'd rather buy one of these.
Re:Sony U50 / U70 ? (Score:2)
And a GLORIOUS 800x600 32bit Bright LCD. not a puny, crappy 16bit 320x240 4 year old screen.
PSP anyone? (Score:1)
It's going to play movies, it will handle music, and it can play PS2 quality games (on a 16:9 screen), the only downside is it has no hard drive, but the UMD discs have a decent enough capacity for my portable media needs, and besides it looks sexy as hell!
Agree, this looks like a PSP ripoff. (Score:2)
Sorry, I don't have 20/10 vision. (Score:4, Insightful)
Does it come with a magnifying lens so I can see what's happening when I play my TV shows and videos? Maybe it's just me, but I find that any video screen smaller than about 10" is completely unwatchable. To make matters worse, mobile video is even more difficult to see on the go because of the variations in ambient light intensity and the jostling motion of walking/commuting/etc.
These mini-video players look like a poor solution to a non-problem.
Name problems? (Score:1, Insightful)
Old news (Score:1, Redundant)
forget CE let's make a instant boot windows device (Score:1)
Forget MSPMC, buy a MEC Station Deluxe (Score:3, Interesting)
6.5" 16:9 Aspect Ratio Screen
20gb, 40gb, 80gb, flavors ($599, $699, $799)
Compact flash support (so you can dump pics from a digicam card STRAIGHT onto the MEC, i.e. if you're on a vacation and need a lot of pic space but only have one card)
TV-out
~4.5 hour battery life
and for the supported media formats...
MPG-1, MPG-2, MPG-4 (DiVX, XViD, RM), JPG, GIF, BMP, WAV, MP3
and in the future...
TXT, OGG
Plus it runs embedded linux variant (not sure which one).
I have one, and it's out NOW. [christopherwu.net]
It rocks. It rocks...
Re:Forget MSPMC, buy a MEC Station Deluxe (Score:2)
PSP might be the answer (Score:1)
I don't think any company apple, dell, M$ has ever come close to the success Sony has had with handheld devices. All the way back from the walkman in the 80s. Sony dominated.
iMovie movie store on the horizen? (Score:1)
This will be great... (Score:2)
Media Center (Score:2)
"iTunes for Video" has been available for many years and it's called Media Center [musicex.com]. Version 10 these days. Plays well with ArchosAV [avsforum.com] and ReplayTV [avsforum.com]. You can even get an iTunes/iPod maxi/mini skin to make you feel right at home...
Re:Media Center (Score:2)
Anyway, not trying to shoot you down here, I'm very glad you pointed these out. I appreciate it.
AllOfMP3.com (Score:2)
Good point, Apple blurred the difference between packaged software and rented software (music) quite well with iTunes.
Media Center plays AACs, but probably not Apple's DRMd AACs unless you use VideoLAN or Hymn to open them up. If I want to play licensed music I suppose I'd use AllOfMp3.com [allofmp3.com] or similar. Let's hear it for global free trade!
Anybody else see what I see? (Score:2)
BSA (Score:2)
All I have to say... (Score:2)
(Except maybe a used/broken one, specificly to crack the DRM).
-
Give us what we want! (Score:2)
Re:No one can beat iPod (Score:5, Insightful)
Designer jeans don't cost so much more because they're necessarily better, or of a higher quality construction, etc..
Re:No one can beat iPod (Score:2)
Re:No one can beat iPod (Score:2)
The difference I see between this and the iPod is that people want, and are used to having, music while on the move. I play my iPod everywhere. I can listen to music when I'm doing pretty much anything, but I can't watch movies in anywhere near so many situations. Portable mo
Actually, I see the point in iPods (Score:2)
Yet I think the iPod probably won on its own merits, not just marketting.
At one point, I actually went looking for an MP3 player. Let me tell you, the impression I was left with was that all the iPod competitors sucked. They sucked like an industrial vacuum cleaner. They sucked like an expensive hooker. That kind of suckage.
The hard drive based ones were larger than a brick. Most still are. (*Cough* Archos.) Looks like everyone just put the c
Size Counts (Score:2)
The larger Archos uses 2.5" HDs so that sets a minimum limit on their size. But the V2 with the lithium cells are much slimmer than before - they fit in my pocket just fine. Then again, I wear combats with plenty of capacious pockets!
One major benefit of 2.5" is the cost - I got my 20GB Archos for $70 after rebate at Amazon. That's pretty amazing. And considering I can expand it to 80GB for around $80 that's compelling. I await the first 100GB 2.5" drives with great i
Re:No one can beat iPod (Score:2)
Re:No one can beat iPod (Score:1)
Re:No one can beat iPod (Score:2)
Re:No one can beat iPod (Score:2)