Review of WidowPC Sting 917 Gaming Laptop 276
Let me start by offering some perspective: most of my gaming is sadly done on a Mac. I have no Mac capable to truly running most modern video games. I always turn the video settings down to just below pathetic, and even then I'm fortunate to get tolerably smooth video. It's just something you sort of learn to accept when you have a Mac. Every game I play on it is just a little short of steller when compared to running on a PC. But my newest Windows capable machine is 3 years old, and a joke by today's standards.
This machine came well equipped: A 3.66ghz P4 w/ 2MB of L2 Cache, 1 gig of 533MHz DDR2 RAM, an Nvidia 6800 Ultra w/ 256MB ram, and not one, but TWO drives, a 60gb 7200 RPM for the OS, and a 100 GB 5400 RPM drive for games. It came in minimal packaging- inside the box was little more than a laptop bag containing the manuals and a few cables. Which is good because all that bloat distracts me from my primary mission: It installed my Warcrack in moments and patched up in probably half the time I was expecting it to take.
With that I hoisted the gigantic beast upon my lap, connected my mouse and began to play. Glorious, lickabley smooth graphics. I turned on every single graphics option and restarted the game, only to discover that there was a level of graphical detail in this game that I didn't know existed. Frames never dropped. Capital cities ceased being slide shows and turned into the bustling metropolis of activity that they are meant to be. 15 man boss fights became liquid fast. In short, having real hardware made my favorite game more fun to play. I'd also like to think it made me a better player, but that might be pushing it.
Likewise the audio gave me a surprising thrill. Walking into rooms and hearing acoustic affects. Voices echoing off walls really give spaces a powerful sense of space. The speakers on this machine are great for laptops. Sure your home stereo sounds better. Hell I bet $50 PC speakers sound better, but for built-ins, it was quite nice.
This new gaming experience does not come without tradeoffs. The first thing you will immediately notice about this monster is the screen. Besides having a 1900x1200 resolution screen, it is incredibly shiny. Frusteratingly so. I found myself closing drapes, turning off lights, and even after that, when I entered a dark room, I'd see my reflection shining back at me. Maybe this is simply a personal preference, but I really struggled to see details in dark scenes. I had to throw the gamma settings way up and sacrifice any contrast to see certain things without straining my eye. This might be the single biggest flaw in the machine.
Next up is weight. This thing is heavy. Everyone I showed this machine to was asked to pick it up. No really, I'd say: pick it up. They'd look at me cockeyed and then comply. Without fail they were surprised at the density of this beast. It was kind of a strange experience, watching people lift and then realize that this thing weighed like 20-30% more than you expect. The website says that this thing weighs 11lbs but it sure felt like more.
The thing is huge. It came with a cheapy little case that fit the laptop quite snuggly, but no other bag in my house came close to carrying it. And I've had some big machines over the years. You should expect to need a custom bag. I never hauled this machine through an airport, but I imagine it would suck wipping this out in security. Even the power cube is gigantic. I've actually had handheld computers about the same size as this thing's power cube.
Also worth noting is heat. There is a giant fan on the left hand side that really does an impressive job of moving the heat outside of the case. And onto whatever is sitting next to you. Let's just say my cats were not so excited to sleep next to me. I've used laptops that were physically uncomfortably hot on the lap, and this machine never got to that point. Instead, it simply would turn off. In the middle of the game. No warning. Very unpleasant. I borrowed a little mini lap desk and then there were no heat problems, provided I left the fans completely unobstructed, and used the machine only on a hard flat surface.
With this giant machine comes a full assortment of ports. And not the miniature custom ports some vendors pass off, but rather full sized real ports without stupid dongles to lose. Of course, since bluetooth and 802.11 is built in, the only port you hopefully will need is power.
The short and long of this machine is that it is heavy and hot. The base model costs $2700 but as I reviewed it, it was more like $3200. And this is one laptop that probably shouldn't be used on your lap: the weight, heat, and random freeze-ups when given improper breathing room pretty well kill that. But if you have the cash to spare, this is a sweet machine. It plays games as well as most any desktop I've seen. It added a level of playability to my favorite game. It has the stones to handle the heaviest 3D games of today, and will likely be able to play the cutting edge games for several weeks into the future. I know most people can't afford a machine like this... but if you can, you'll definitely be envied by your friends next time you haul it out at a LAN party... it's a hell of a lot sexier than lugging around a monitor and a mini-atx based machine. I'm sad to let the review unit go back to WidowPC.
Nothing for you to see here. Please move along. (Score:4, Insightful)
Wheres the picture or links to another review (Score:4, Insightful)
Re:Wheres the picture or links to another review (Score:5, Informative)
Re:Wheres the picture or links to another review (Score:3, Funny)
Re:Wheres the picture or links to another review (Score:2)
Re:Wheres the picture or links to another review (Score:2)
Re:Wheres the picture or links to another review (Score:2)
Re:Wheres the picture or links to another review (Score:2)
Links & Reviews (Score:3, Informative)
http://www.resellerratings.com/seller8781-p3-s1-d
http://laptop-notebook.blogspot.com/ [blogspot.com]
No link? (Score:3, Insightful)
Re:No link? (Score:2, Informative)
Re:No link? (Score:2)
Can you run the dnetc "benchmark"? (Score:2, Interesting)
While not a perfect benchmark by any means, and highly dependent upon which core is used (ie. the algorithm and implementation), it is often a useful test to quantify how a machine performs.
Re:Can you run the dnetc "benchmark"? (Score:2)
Here's what I don't understand... (Score:5, Insightful)
Re:Here's what I don't understand... (Score:3, Interesting)
Truely, this is a "desktop replacement" - desktop specs, smaller footprint. I equate this to something like an iMac. But the up side is if you leave IN the battery, a brownout/blackout won't stop the machine, lose any work, or fry your innards. So this is a small-footprint desktop gaming PC with built-in battery backup. Sounds ok to me.
Re:Here's what I don't understand... (Score:2)
In any case, if it does happen that often - e.g., you live in California or some third-world country with an unreliable power grid - wouldn't you be better off getting a UPS? I've gotta believe that a SFF desk
Re:Here's what I don't understand... (Score:2)
That's the difference between buying a SFF and buying a desktop-replacement notebook. Low-end desktop replacements are CHEAP, too... acceptable specs for under $1000 from Dell, versus gamer specs for $3000 from this company.
Re:Here's what I don't understand... (Score:2)
Re:Here's what I don't understand... (Score:2)
Re:Here's what I don't understand... (Score:2)
Re:Here's what I don't understand... (Score:2)
In any case, if it does happen that often - e.g., you live in California or some third-world country with an unreliable power grid - wouldn't you be better off getting a UPS? I've gotta believe that a SFF desktop with comparable specs + UPS is still less than this thing costs.
I live in an apartment complex in NJ, and man alive is the power setup horrible. Probably originally wired in the 60s, and that was the last time. Brownouts and power surges are a regular thing, as are blackouts during - I shit y
Re:Here's what I don't understand... (Score:2)
Re:Here's what I don't understand... (Score:2)
Central Pennsylvania may not qualify as a "third-world country", but I guess in some respects it's close.
In the small town where I live, we only have maybe 2 or 3 "sustained" blackouts a year. By that I mean more than a few seconds, typically minutes our hours. But far more common (about twice a month) is the power "blink", where some idiot drunk driver hits a pole a few miles a
Comment removed (Score:5, Funny)
Here's a link to the manufacturers page (Score:2, Informative)
Re:Here's a link to the manufacturers page (Score:2)
Ummm (Score:2, Interesting)
Re:Ummm (Score:4, Interesting)
Re:Ummm (Score:5, Funny)
He's CmdrTaco, 'editor'-in-chief of this 'ere Slashdot.
Why did they get their free loaner (to advertise here perhaps)
He's CmdrTaco, 'editor'-in-chief of this 'ere Slashdot.
He's CmdrTaco, 'editor'-in-chief of this 'ere Slashdot.
Re:Ummm (Score:2)
Re:Ummm (Score:2)
Link to said laptop (Score:5, Informative)
I read teh review, was like ok, it's big, but what's inside?
Here it is:
Re:Link to said laptop (Score:2)
I'll grant that that laptop has a few nice bells and whistles, but nothing Alienware or even the Dell XPS's don't offer. (yeah, both my laptops are/were from Dell).
1900x1200 is not "wide" 19:12, 14.25:9 or 4.75:3 (Score:2)
I guess everyone loves the GlareBright (tm) screens too.
Re:1900x1200 is not "wide" 19:12, 14.25:9 or 4.75: (Score:3, Insightful)
Re:Link to said laptop (Score:3, Interesting)
Check THIS [eurocom.com] out.
Its a Eurocom F-Bomb. Here are some specs:
Superb 17.1-inch WUXGA 1920-by-1200 pixels with Super Clear Glossy Surface
- Fully 64-bit capable supernotebook
- Processor: socket based, fully upgradeable, single or dual core, 64-bit
* up to 4800+ AMD Athlon 64 X2 Dual Core; 939-pin; 1MB cache
* up to 4000+ AMD Athlon 64 FX57; 939-pin; 1MB cache; single core
- Memory: up to 2GB DDR400 SODIMM; 2 sockets
- Choice of Video with EUROCOM upgradeable VGA technology:
* 25
Off the Mark (Score:5, Insightful)
That said, who has a lap big enough for it? Let me give you the key points:
Dimensions: 15.6"(W) x 11.7"(D) x 1.95"(H)
Weight: 11.3 lbs. with Battery
That is almost the size of two reams of paper .
Product Link [widowpc.com] for reference.
Re:Off the Mark (Score:2)
Other than that... a paperweight you spent WAY too much for.
"Osbourne One" portability (Score:2)
Sure seems like you'd use this almost exclusively for the LAN party circuit. It's pitched at the niche market of gamers too. I guess we're sick of toting our cables and whatnot around by now.
Re:Off the Mark (Score:2)
Made by Clevo (Score:5, Informative)
Re:Made by Clevo (Score:3, Informative)
The Definition Of.... (Score:2)
Seriously, wait 18 months and the price of this rig drops by 50%. Until then, I'm quite content to play in 1024x768 at 60Hz with medium textures; and you know, it doesn't bother me in the least.
See you in the land of the lagless low ping times!
Re:The Definition Of.... (Score:2)
Re:The Definition Of.... (Score:2)
Don't do that. 800x600 at 72Hz is okay, but 60Hz is more than likely to give you a headache.
Re:The Definition Of.... (Score:2)
Don't do that. 800x600 at 72Hz is okay, but 60Hz is more than likely to give you a headache.
It's a safe bet that he is referring to a flat panel. I picked up a dirt cheap 15" flat panel and saved the box so I could cart it to LAN parties. Combine that with a Shuttle-like system, easy to move, low footprint,
Re:The Definition Of.... (Score:2)
I used a laptop for gaming until I got serious. (Score:4, Interesting)
- more power
- less neck sores (adjustable height monitor)
- bigger monitor
- cheaper than getting something equivalent in laptop form
The only downside is that I love laptop keyboards. If anyone knew of a place where I could buy a plugable USB keyboard the size and shape similar to what you would find on a laptop it would make me really happy for xmas.
Re:I used a laptop for gaming until I got serious. (Score:4, Informative)
Some laptop-sized keyboards (Score:2)
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.asp?Item=N8 2 E16823166015 [newegg.com]
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.asp?Item=N [newegg.com]
See them here (Score:4, Informative)
http://www.sagernotebook.com/pages/web_specials.h
At PCTorque:
http://www.pctorque.com/sager-laptops.php [pctorque.com]
A sample desktop screenshot, wsxga:
http://public.fotki.com/Marspoet/desktops/windowm
Place where people talk about them:
http://www.notebookforums.com/ [notebookforums.com]
Extra Paragraph (Score:5, Funny)
This may be the system's biggest flaw.
Re:Extra Paragraph (Score:3, Insightful)
Comparing these to light and mobile laptops is a false comparison as that is not what these machines are made to be or do.
Cheers
Re:Extra Paragraph (Score:3, Interesting)
I'm getting the 17" PowerBook shortly, and I have to say its resolution looks pretty good. I don't think I could read type much smaller, so I'm not sure how much gain higher resolution gives you, and I'm a screen size junkie (I have a 23" Cinema Display which is 1920x1200, or the same resolution as the test lapto
Re:Extra Paragraph (Score:2)
Re:Extra Paragraph (Score:2)
Re:Extra Paragraph (Score:2)
Sleek, sexy, and *small* would be envied! (Score:5, Funny)
Personally, I would guess that your friends would be far more envious if you had a super sleek machine that wasn't noisy, hot, and HUGE but still offered good graphics, response, and the *possibily* of child rearing if you could get a girl.
That's me though.
Re:Sleek, sexy, and *small* would be envied! (Score:2)
This is slashdot. That statement can be optimised out of existence.
I remember paying that for a 286 (Score:2)
Sure its alot of money, but I'm sure many people here remember buying a 286 system when they first came out for 2-3 thousand with a monochrome display and a 10meg harddrive :) I still have a 286 laptop in the basement if anyone is interested. It only weighs like 15lb and has a battery life of 20 minutes ;)
http://religiousfreaks.com/ [religiousfreaks.com]Re:I remember paying that for a 286 (Score:2)
Picture? (Score:2)
Hmm.. no real information... (Score:5, Insightful)
How about some links to real reviews?
Such as:
http://laptopmag.com/Review/WidowPC-Sting-917.htm [laptopmag.com]- 1 [gamespot.com] g +917+ [google.com]
http://hardware.gamespot.com/Story-ST-23446-x-1-3
and
http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&q=WidowPC+Stin
While this is an interesting writeup... lack of REAL information AND LINKS makes this kinda pointless (At least he didn't link to his blog that has the same writeup)
And at the other end of the scale... (Score:2)
The only downside to the X505 is that it's *very* costly. But if you buy one portable every three or four years, like me, and you take it everywhere you go, it's absolutely perfect.
It weighs just under 2lb, 800g, btw.
Re:Yes, but does it run linux? (Score:2)
I did not get the impression the review was aimed at a "games machine"... it was more of a "see how much we can pack into a box" style of thing. My point was that sometimes, the "see how much we can remove from the box" can lead to very useful designs.
Why, o god why (Score:2)
i surfed arround widowpc's site, and it appears they dont offer any of there really huge laptops like this with pentium m's. just athlon 64 X2's and P4's, only the "lesser models" come with pentium M's which they themselves describe as "faster than the pentium 4!". someone dropped the ball.. hmm
Warcrack? (Score:2)
Re:Warcrack? (Score:2)
Dimensions: 15.6"(W) x 11.7"(D) x 1.95"(H)
Wait for the AMD X2 dualcore version (Score:3, Informative)
Christmas Time Songs fill my mind... (Score:5, Funny)
Chestnuts Roasting While I Open Fire...
[slashdot readers boo and hiss...]
(go ahead...mod it down. I've got karma to burn)
Translation : (Score:2)
> most of my gaming is sadly done on a Mac. I have no Mac capable to truly running most modern video games.
> my newest Windows capable machine is 3 years old, and a joke by today's standards.
Where's the actual review ?
All you said was "this laptop is big and here are some features"
Taco, you're no gamer, stop pretending you are to look cool. If you had a "primary gaming machine" you'd talk ab
Re:Translation : (Score:2)
Yup, agreed. WoW (or "warcrack" in some mad attempt to be "leet") doesn't make you a hardcore gamer.
-everphilski-
Re:Translation : (Score:2)
'Cause gamers are cool! Ask any girl!
Re:Translation : (Score:2)
There aren't many things you need a decent machine for at home :
DV video editing
3D Rendering
Games
Big compiles
are the things I can think of.
Seems Taco has a laptop and doesn't know what to use it for. It's got a 6800 in it and games are the only thing that he knows will make it hit 100% CPU.
Do you think "Hey I got a new laptop" is front page news ?
I misread the title (Score:2)
My first thought was "sitting since 9/17? I hope he patches it before playing any games"
Send it to school! (Score:2)
http://angryflower.com/bobsqu.gif [angryflower.com]
But... (Score:2)
No, really, the review doesn't make any mention of how easy it is to install say Fedora on the thing, or how much of the hardware is supported. I find this very surprising for Slashdot of all sites.
UK equivalent (Score:2)
Please note... (Score:2)
Editor?! (Score:2)
Re:Editor?! (Score:2)
I know it's not always easy to come up with descriptive language, but CmdrTaco just admitted he's the one who created goatse guy (with his "gigantic beast").
It doesn't beat this one... (Score:2)
This was my first computer, I got it as a hand-me-down from my dad and it was portable! I think it only weighted something like 17 kilos. Thank you dad, love you!
Aaah, the days when one had to change fuses inside the computer
Gaming on a Mac (Score:5, Insightful)
My desktop Mac is primarily used for video editing and graphics work, but I just find Taco's statement unfortunate, because it just perpetuates the "Macs suck at Gaming" myth. My God, Taco's "laptop" is freakin' $3,400. It sounds like the only thing it has going for it is that it's easy to pack up to a LAN party. You aren't going to pull this out on an Airline tray. The batterly life must suck. It's hot, heavy, not particularly good looking (IMHO). In short, it has almost no features that I would look for in a laptop.
I don't know, I suppose this kind of bohemoth will probably appeal to the kind of guy who thinks he'll look L33T to everyone around him because he's got the biggest, noisiest, hottest laptop in the room. When in reality the guys with the sleak Vaio's and PowerBooks are just laughing at him.
The other day I was sitting in a hotel cafe and this guy's struggling to fit his gigantic laptop on his "table-built-for-two" and still have room for his breakfast. He was pounding proudly away on it. I just felt sorry for him because he kept getting dirty looks from the waitress who had to keep stepping over the powercord he'd strung about 10 feet to the wall. I thought about pulling my TiBook out, but that would have just been low.
Re:Gaming on a Mac (Score:2)
this is a Pro-Star machine (Score:2, Informative)
i have this same system (Score:3, Informative)
I don't understand this market. (Score:4, Insightful)
You can also buy a 12" PowerBook for that much. It weighs 4.6lb, and gets 5 hours of battery life (half-bright screen and WiFi off; turn on WiFi to start with 4.5hr). My 12" plays WoW alright (although my desktop does it better).
Alternatively, you can pay a bit more, and get a little ShuttlePC that has a nice projector output. Lug it around in your backpack (after all, it's going to be 8-10lb), and it's about as portable as this Widow PC.
Or, for the price of both the desktop and the PowerBook (or a Shuttle and a cheaper x86 laptop), you can buy this monster which weighs 11-13lb (depending on whose specs you read), and gets 57 minutes (!) of battery life. Plus you can't upgrade the thing when it's out of date in a year or two (like a friend of mine who had a Dell gamer laptop he hated). That laptop is the same as if I took 3 12" PBs and stacked them up in terms up weight, and gets roughly 1/15th as much battery life (57 minutes vs. 15 hours of 3 PBs).
You might as well buy a 17" widescreen PowerBook, which comes equipped with some very sexy specs, is thin, and gets up to 5.5hr of battery life. You'd only buy such a "laptop" as a penis extension!
Games on the slower drive? (Score:2)
60gb is a lot of room, honestly. Put your OS and your games, both which require a lot of disk I/O on the faster drive. Put your MP3s, browser cache, etc. on the slower drive, since these things require fewer continuous reads from the drive over their use.
This will reduce the time staring at loading screens by a noticable amount
Reviewer has no basis for comparison (Score:2)
Strange choice of hard drives (Score:3, Interesting)
My Review (Score:3, Informative)
WidowPC is also able to deliver these laptops, fully customized, in 2 business days! Compare that to Alienware's several weeks for the same piece of equipment (Clevo D900T).
On the downside:
Sounds Perfect (Score:3, Interesting)
Now I just need some Pringles cans and a 30 mile high antenna tower so I can get LOS to somewhere with an internet connection.
Sager notebook (Score:3, Interesting)
http://www.sagernotebook.com/pages/go_np9750.html [sagernotebook.com]
Hardware RAID, 2 CD-ROM drive bays, TV Tuner (optional), subwoofer, DVI, remote control, the works. And all in a compact 12.5 pound package! Ok, it is big but won't blind your eyes like the one above.
Re:Seriously... (Score:4, Interesting)
LAN parties! While I certainly wouldn't call it a laptop it is certainly more portable than some of the rigs I've seen with carrying straps wrapped around them. A built-in screen is much nicer than lugging a heavy CRT around with you, too.
Aside from the gaming aspect, it would still be nice to have a fairly heavy-duty station for 'regular work' which you can take from site to site. Again, you're not going to get much use from the battery, but anywhere you can sit and plug-in would be fine. The $3200 price is a little offputting, but I suppose that's the price you pay (pun intended) for the convenience of a portable game-capable workstation.
Re:No Mac? (Score:2)
Putting a brand new V8 in a Model T and claiming it "runs well for a 80 year old car" isn't really in the spirit..
That said, I'm always astounded at how well old Macs keep going. I know a design company who still run Macs from the mid 90s as their main machines!
Re:Learn to spell "its", darn it. (Score:2)
Re:Sing along! (Score:2)
I hereby claim that comment, thus removing it from anonymity!
Re:Sing along! (Score:2)
*goes back to his corner*
Re:no wi-fi !? (Score:3, Informative)
"Of course, since bluetooth and 802.11 is built in, the only port you hopefully will need is power."
Guess again.